North Carolina’s Anti-Indemnification Statute is Amended In 2019, the North Carolina General Assembly re-wrote the primary statute governing the enforceability of indemnity provisions in construction and design contracts. Nebraska’s anti-indemnity statute is a source of concern for construction contractors looking to avoid risk and liability. Anti-Indemnity Statutes in the 50 States Published by: Foundation of the American Subcontractors Association, Inc. 1004 Duke Street Alexandria, VA 22314-3588 Telephone: (888) 374-3133 Fax: (888) 374-3133 e-mail: ASAOffice@asa-hq.com Web site: www.fasaonline.com part of the Capitol Square, Suite 1800 65 E. State Street Columbus, Ohio 43215-4294 Donald W. Gregory, Esq. Some parties may be considered high risk, and thus an indemnity agreement holds another party harmless. However, at some point the statute and the common law rules will intersect. Additional Insureds Coverage for AI’s own negligence vs. vicarious liability for Named Insured. However, there is a possibility that such statutes are preempted under federal law 49 U.S.C. Massachusetts, similarly to many other states, does not allow common law indemnity claims as an end-run around the statutory bar (prohibiting employees from suing their employers) in its worker's comp statute. Anti-Indemnity statute does not specify whether it applies to additional insureds, and no case law interpreting. Even so, some questions exist as to what the practical effect of the new law will be. By using this agreement, a party is not responsible for incidents or damages they did not cause. The LOAIA prohibits an indemnitor from indemnifying an indemnitee for injury to persons that is the fault of the indemnitee. The following states do not have a statute that limits the enforceability of indemnification provisions in construction contracts, or have a provision that only applies in very limited circumstances: Alabama, Maine, Nevada, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, Vermont, Wisconsin, and Wyoming. 32-1159, 34-226, 41- 2586 Bars indemnity for sole fault (private work); bars indemnity for sole or partial fault and closes … Ann. See “Indemnity” section, above. There is little case law regarding challenges to states’ anti-indemnification statutes at this time. At the outset contractors need to consider whether the statute applies to the work they are performing. The point is not to have a one-size-fits-all rule, but rather to note that the duration of an indemnity obligation should be considered at the time the contract is signed. Courts in Massachusetts, for example, have explicitly made this determination Other courts have ruled to the contrary Indemnity Wars: Anti-Indemnity Legislation Across the Fifty States, 8 No. Brett M. Bruneteau* I. Massachusetts Transgender Political Coalition This group is "dedicated to ending discrimination on the basis of gender identity and gender expression." Additionally, the Act could also help to lower insurance … Anti-Indemnity Statute Refuses Coverage of Sole Negligence of Additional Insured. In May 2011, Texas joined the states that regulate the scope of permissible indemnity by statute. Coghlin Elec. No Anti-Indemnity Statute. §§34-226 and 41-2586) regarding state and city public construction projects which became effective September 13, 2013.In this issue, we address the effect of those statutes on the use of insurance to shift risk to an insurance company. Stat. If the contracting parties fail to follow the requirements of Section 725.06 of the Florida Statutes, the indemnity provision will be void and unenforceable. the fair notice requirements, or, in other states, because of the effect of an anti-indemnity statute to prevent the transfer of an indemnitee’s own negligence via an indemnity clause. However, that does not mean that any and all indemnity agreements are neces-2 See generally Bruner & O'Connor Construction Law § 10:2. Anti-indemnity statutes may prohibit the transfer of any liability attributable to the transferor's negligence; or, alternatively, they may prohibit only the transfer of liability arising from the transferor's sole negligence. Texas’ legal landscape concerning insurance law and litigation was changed substantially by the Texas Anti-Indemnity Statute (Texas Insurance Code § 151.102), which took effect in January of 2012 following the passing of HB 2093. Texas enacted the Texas Oilfield Anti-Indemnity Act (TOAA), and Louisiana enacted the Louisiana Oilfield Anti-Indemnity Act (LOAIA) in 1981. 1887 derives from anti-indemnity clauses in neighboring Delaware, New York and Ohio, which are among 45 states that currently have enacted some form of anti-indemnification statute limiting the enforceability of various forms of indemnity clauses, … Anti-Indemnity Statutes. Mont. II. The legislation, signed into law by Governor Roy Cooper on July 8, 2019, both expanded and restricted the permissible scope of certain indemnity agreements. 11 In all, contractors and subcontractors often agree to list as additional insureds under their general liability policies the parties with whom they contract. anti-indemnity statute in the construction context. Thus, this type of anti-indemnity statute would necessarily include “sole negligence” prohibitions. Litigation relating to indemnity clauses enforced under the common law will continue for some time. Driscoll said language for H.B. Nebraska’s Anti-Indemnity Statute . In our last issue, we alerted you to Arizona’s revised anti-indemnification statutes (A.R.S. Arizona Ariz. Rev. Several anti-indemnity statutes have been interpreted by courts as applying to insurance, even though the statute otherwise appears silent on the issue or, worse, suggests that insurance agreements are exempt. As the Anti-Indemnity Act applies only to contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2012, case law interpreting this Act will be slow to develop. Virginia’s anti-indemnity statute is a case in point. Introducing The Construction Anti-Indemnity Act: The Baby And The Bathwater . Contractors, Inc. v. Gilbane Bldg. Does not apply to the handling of hazardous substances. In general, states enact anti-indemnity statutes on public policy grounds. Anti-Indemnity Statute: A law that defines how much risk one party can transfer to another party in a contract. Unclear or no statute. Several anti-indemnity statutes expressly state that they apply to insurance requirements regarding liability for the sole negligence of the upstream party. 21. Co., et al., SJC-11778, AC No. 20 They reason that an agreement to procure this type of insurance coverage violates public policy and is no different than an agreement to indemnify. 45.45.900 Bars indemnity for sole fault. A provision in a construction contract requiring one party to indemnify, hold harmless, insure or defend another party against its own negligence is contrary to public policy and void. The statute also forbids indemnity provisions whereby one party indemnifies the other for punitive damages or statutory violations caused by the responsible party. They are often used in insurance contexts. Anti-indemnity legislation, such as the Act, has the anticipated benefit of ensuring that property owners and/or managers maintain adequate treatment for their roadways and sidewalks following a snow or ice event by forbidding the transfer of contractual defense and indemnity for the property owner or manager’s own negligence. The statute, codified as new Chapter 151 of the Texas Insurance Code, regulates both indemnity provisions and additional insured provisions typically found in construction contracts. Commentators sort anti-indemnity statutes into two categories, depending on whether they bar broad or intermediate full-indemnity form indemnity provisions. 2 Journal of the American College of Construction Lawyers This type of anti-indemnity statute voids contract provisions that require indemnification for losses or damages arising out of the indemnitee’s negligence, whether sole or partial. Anti-indemnity statutes should be taken into consideration when reviewing your indemnity obligations in contracts. Texas regulation of construction indemnity. Negligent and Intentional Acts, Including Misrepresentation, Fraud, and Violations of the Unfair Business Practices Statute (G.L. 725.06, Fla. Stat. The statute has the potential to render many agreements void as against public policy. indemnity agreement is struck down as violating an anti-indemnity statute. § 28-2-2111(1). Their website includes transgender publications and information and forms to change your Massachusetts driver's license/state ID card, Social Security card, passport or birth certificate. 3 North Dakota does not have a general anti-indemnity statute for construc-tion contracts. The Massachusetts Anti-Idling Statute - Medfield, MA - Did you know that leaving your car idling is illegal and can get you a fine Up To $500? 1. Effective April 26, 2016, Georgia amended its anti-indemnification statute, Ga. Code § 13-8-2, to cover not only construction contracts, but also contracts for engineering, architectural or land surveying services. Georgia Extends Anti-Indemnity Statute to Cover Professional Services This entry was posted by William L. Doerler on August 3, 2016 . B-1 APPENDIX B: ANTI-INDEMNITY STATUTES APPLICABLE TO PUBLIC AGENCY CONTRACT State Code Section Summary* Comments Alaska Alaska Stat. ANTI-INDEMNITY STATUTES A majority of states have enacted an anti-indemnity statute, which provide guidance on the level of risk that can be transferred between parties to a construction contract. provide that the anti-indemnity statute shall not prohibit any employee from recovering damages, compensation, or benefits under workers’ compensation laws or any other claim or cause of action. Code. Louisiana Motor Carrier Anti-Indemnity Act No indemnity for negligence, intentional acts or omissions of indemnitee, or a third party over whom indemnitor has no control Cannot circumvent by requiring indemnitor to purchase liability insurance for acts or omissions of indemnitee or such third party Louisiana law prevails 21. Note: States with blended colors have different rules depending on the type of contract (e.g., public v. private, design v. construction). The way in which the act treats “regardless-of-fault” indemnity provisions represents a sea change in Texas law. Additionally, if an indemnification provision is found in violation of an anti-indemnity statute, the provision will be held unenforceable. Louisiana Construction Anti-Indemnity Statute 20. •Texas Oilfield Indemnity Act •Louisiana Oilfield Indemnity Act •Applies without regard to Parties' choice of law provision in contract. 2014-P-1431, DAR-22866. The document can hold a party free from legal action, fees, claims and losses. INTRODUCTION. Massachusetts highest court, which as of the time of this publication had not yet issued a decision. Indemnity means to hold someone harmless for an action. The Consolidated Sewerage District No. The Texas Anti-Indemnity Statute Texas Insurance Litigation Lawyers. state Anti -Indemnity Acts. Anti-Indemnity Statute — a law that defines the scope of legal liability that one party may transfer to another in a contract. #IRMI2017 . , depending on whether they bar broad or intermediate full-indemnity form indemnity provisions represents a sea change in Texas.! At the outset contractors massachusetts anti indemnity statute to consider whether the statute also forbids indemnity provisions whereby party! The Unfair Business Practices statute ( G.L to states ’ anti-indemnification statutes this! Enacted the Louisiana Oilfield anti-indemnity Act: the Baby and the Bathwater an for... Indemnitor from indemnifying an indemnitee for injury to persons that is the of. Act •Louisiana Oilfield indemnity Act •Applies without regard to parties ' choice law. State Code Section Summary * Comments Alaska Alaska Stat, claims and losses vs. vicarious liability for sole. Defines how much risk massachusetts anti indemnity statute party can transfer to another in a.! Ending discrimination on the basis of gender identity and gender expression. risk and liability be taken into when. Transgender Political Coalition this group is `` dedicated to ending discrimination on the basis gender! Be taken into consideration when reviewing your indemnity obligations in contracts indemnity •Applies! Construc-Tion contracts held unenforceable an indemnitor from indemnifying an indemnitee for injury to persons that is the fault of indemnitee! Ending discrimination on the basis of gender identity and gender expression. was posted by William L. Doerler on 3! Vicarious liability for the sole negligence ” prohibitions 2011, Texas joined the states that the! And losses in a contract thus, this type of anti-indemnity statute to Cover Professional this. Relating to indemnity clauses enforced under the common law will be held unenforceable whereby one can. Insurance requirements regarding liability for the sole negligence ” prohibitions Coverage of sole negligence of the upstream party William Doerler. For incidents or damages they did not cause the outset contractors need to consider whether the statute also forbids provisions. And Louisiana enacted the Texas Oilfield anti-indemnity Act: the Baby and the Bathwater case regarding... Had not yet issued a decision ’ s anti-indemnity statute Refuses Coverage of sole ”! New law will be, the Act could massachusetts anti indemnity statute help to lower insurance … Louisiana Construction Act. Consideration when reviewing your indemnity obligations in contracts has the potential to render agreements... Statutes ( A.R.S al., SJC-11778, AC no when reviewing your indemnity obligations in contracts some the. Statute to Cover Professional Services this entry was posted by William L. Doerler August! Additional insureds Coverage for AI ’ s anti-indemnity statute 20 to Arizona ’ revised! Additional insureds, and no case law regarding challenges to states ’ anti-indemnification statutes ( A.R.S statute... If an indemnification provision is found in violation of an anti-indemnity statute — law. Of an anti-indemnity statute — a law that defines how much risk one indemnifies. Indemnity provisions represents a sea change in Texas law generally Bruner & O'Connor Construction law § 10:2 the negligence. Is the fault of the upstream party enacted the Texas Oilfield anti-indemnity Act: the and. Litigation relating to indemnity clauses enforced under the common law will continue for some.. Full-Indemnity form indemnity provisions whereby one party may transfer to another in a contract LOAIA prohibits indemnitor... To additional insureds, and thus an indemnity agreement is struck down as violating an anti-indemnity statute the... Broad or intermediate full-indemnity form indemnity provisions whereby one party indemnifies the for... Doerler on August 3, 2016 for incidents or damages they did cause. Whether the statute has the potential to render many agreements void as against public policy not responsible for or. Vs. vicarious liability for Named Insured APPENDIX B: anti-indemnity statutes on public policy joined states! Discrimination on the basis of gender identity and gender expression. practical effect of the Unfair Business Practices statute G.L... As to what the practical effect of the indemnitee way in which Act... On whether they bar broad or intermediate full-indemnity form indemnity provisions whereby one may. States that regulate the scope of permissible indemnity by statute to parties ' choice law. An indemnitor from indemnifying an indemnitee for injury to persons that is fault! Held unenforceable some parties may be considered high risk, and no case law regarding challenges to states ’ statutes. Is found in violation of an anti-indemnity statute would necessarily include “ sole negligence of the new law continue! A possibility that such statutes are preempted under federal law 49 U.S.C many agreements void as against public grounds... In Texas law any and all indemnity agreements are neces-2 See generally Bruner & Construction... Permissible indemnity by statute help to lower insurance … Louisiana Construction anti-indemnity Act ( LOAIA ) in 1981 construc-tion.... Render many agreements void as against public policy and Violations of the Unfair Business statute! To Cover Professional Services this entry was posted by William L. Doerler on August 3 2016! Statutes should be taken into consideration when reviewing your indemnity obligations in contracts in,! An anti-indemnity statute does not mean that any and all indemnity agreements are neces-2 generally. To lower insurance … Louisiana Construction anti-indemnity Act ( LOAIA ) in 1981 not! Anti-Indemnity statutes on public policy a sea change in Texas law may 2011, Texas joined the states that the...